SIP Forum's Smart Grid Group: Why SIP Is the Best Protocol and Architecture for Demand and Response

By IoTevolutionworld Special Guest
Arjun Roychowdhury, Co-chair, SIP Forum Smart Grid Group and Assistant Vice President, Smart Energy, Hughes Systique Corporation
June 21, 2010
Toward the end of 2009, SIP Forum started a task force dedicated to evaluating the application of the Session Initiation Protocol in the Smart Grid ecosystem. The origins of this group were previously covered in an article I wrote for this portal here. Six months later, the group has over 100 members across a wide spectrum of companies (Utilities, Service Providers, OEMs, ISVs etc.) and has produced several key approach notes and white papers that further outline the relevance of the role SIP can play in the Smart Grid ecosystem.
Some of the documents created by members of this group will additional insight:
The bottom line, so to speak, is based on the contributions made, it is clear that the flexibility of SIP makes it an appropriate choice for a variety of functions across the Smart Grid space. SIP can significantly reduce costs and time to market for all the players, simply because SIP is already proven and widely deployed in both enterprise and residential networks today, handling VoIP, IM, presence, and event services, many of which are applicable to the Smart Grid network. 
One of the primary goals of this group is to educate people on the various functions of SIP beyond handling voice calls and to that goal, this group recently published a significant white paper on the applicability of SIP for implementing a scalable Demand and Response system. The paper, authored by Hughes Systique Corporation, can be downloaded here, and is posted on this portal as well.
What is Demand and Response?
Simply put, Demand and Response is a mechanism to manage consumption of electricity in response to supply conditions, price of electricity and other parameters. Defining it further, a Demand Response program is a critical component, typically developed and offered by Utility companies or ISOs that offer participants to contribute effectively for better energy load management/reduction. 
Typical participants include individuals as well as small and large corporations. A DR program typically ties in with a dynamic pricing scheme for electricity where participants, and depending on a variety of factors (such as time of day, price etc.) can actively participate in requesting a Utility for increase or reduction of electricity demand. While this helps in cost reduction for participants, it significantly helps Utility/ISOs reduce their own cost and manage distribution of electricity (which is a finite resource) better. Several Utilities/ISOs offer incentive programs to participants for taking part in DR programs. In addition to DR, automation of DR is a key concept which helps reduce human intervention and increases accuracy and responsiveness to the DR program.
How is Demand Response done today?
Interestingly, DR is a surprisingly primitive operation today. Traditionally, many components of DR have been a manual process. Usually, an industrial administrator would monitor DR events and manually react to peak pricing indications. For enterprises which did not have dedicated personnel, there are several aggregators who liaise between the Utility and the enterprise customer and perform such monitoring; and when system peak load reaches close to critical peak, they inform the enterprise customers to start shedding load.
While there is a degree of automation here, this too involves significant manual intervention. Often, indications are delivered to customers over phone calls or even in-person visits. Furthermore, there is no standard in DR which is widely used. Therefore, any automation, however small is mostly proprietary.
Okay, remind me, why is Demand and Response so important then if it is not being done much now?
Well, DR is being done now. Just not in an automated fashion. And because DR is not automated, it makes deployment of DR expensive for utilities. But why is DR important? Because unless you can do effective management of Demand and Response, Utilities will not be able to manage their peak loads, and will hit critical loads more often than required. The impact of this is significant. FERC has a white paper on the importance of DR which can be downloaded here.
Got it, so what are the Standard bodies doing about this and how is SIP better?
The OpenADR research has created a specification that lays out an architecture for an automated and interoperable end-to-end Demand and Response system. NIST has endorsed this architecture as well. Effectively, OpenADR specifies abstract template and procedures for an automated DR system. The Open ADR architecture is a perfect fit for SIP because SIP has a powerful Event system which is exactly what automated DR is all about - it's a mechanism to:
  • Publish new DR events
  • Subscribe to new DR events
  • Allow participants to participate or not participate in DR events
  • Manage and audit subscriptions
  • Do all of the above securely
  • Do all of the above asynchronously
Interestingly, this is what forms the backbone of the SIP Events architecture and it is already proven - all enterprises and operators that deploy VoIP use this events architecture for presence!
The OpenADR has also implemented a version of the specifications via Web Services, but we believe that SIP offers a significantly more scalable and powerful solution while adhering to the OpenADR architecture at the same time (in other words, SIP is better than HTTP for this purpose).
For more detail, please read our paper hereHughes Systique Corp. has also implemented a proof of concept of such a system by re-using existing open source SIP servers. It is our hope that more people evaluate the power of SIP for such applications and make their own decisions as a result.
For any questions related to this paper or approach, feel free to email

IoTevolutionworld publishes expert commentary on various telecommunications, IT, call center, CRM and other technology-related topics. Are you an expert in one of these fields, and interested in having your perspective published on a site that gets several million unique visitors each month? Get in touch.

Edited by Michael Dinan

Related Articles

Telit Provides Cat M1 IoT Module for NTT Smart Cities Trial

By: Ken Briodagh    6/15/2018

In a recent release, Telit announced that its ME910C1-J1 is being used in a Smart City field trial by NTT DoCoMo in Fujisawa.

Read More

The Blockchain GDPR Puzzle: An Expert Weighs In

By: Cynthia S. Artin    6/11/2018

Akshay Sharma, Principal Analyst for the boutique advisory firm neXt-Curve, shared strong views in a note published last month on the potential to inv…

Read More

Summer Boot Camp: Gateway to Enterprise IOT?

By: Cynthia S. Artin    6/5/2018

June is a beautiful month to be in Canada, and at the LoRa Alliance All Members Meeting and Open House, Senet and Laird will be hosting a boot camp of…

Read More

Curvature is Curving IT Lifecycle Services for Data Centers

By: Chrissie Cluney    6/5/2018

Curvature is the world's largest provider of third-party maintenance and multi-vendor network and data center IT lifecycle services.

Read More

eleven-x Launches LoRaWAN Solutions for Smart City and Enterprise IoT

By: Ken Briodagh    5/31/2018

eleven-x has launched a new platform designed to enable easy and secure wireless LoRaWAN connectivity for currently deployed but unconnected Smart Cit…

Read More